Friday, February 24, 2006

A time for Zorro.

I don’t know Jessica Lall.
In any case, a few hundreds are murdered in this country everyday.
Why then, should Jessica Lall make me feel so helpless?

Preity Zinta made a point on TV.
You can get a year, she said, for blackbuck.
But you can kill a person and get way with it.

It’s true.

A few notable examples.
Manu Sharma.
Admiral Nanda’s grandson.
Kunhalikutty.
Ameeta Modi and Sanjay Singh.
Amar Mani Tripathi.
Natwar Singh and son.

Clout circumventing the judicial process is old hat.
The issue today, is not that.

The issue is that all the above, are still welcome in our society.
They continue to hold offices.
They are still part of the social circuit.

This, their brazenness and our acceptance, spells doom.
It means that today’s Indian society, you and me included, are willing to condone murder.
Willing to condone the castration of justice.
Willing to turn a blind eye to anything that doesn’t directly involve us.
Willing to tolerate injustice.
Too ready, to forgive and forget.

We as a society have degenerated.
The letter of the law is strictly the letter of the law.
No longer does it hold a moral value for us.

It’s getting caught therefore, that makes crime a crime.
Not so much the act.

We don’t have a collective conscience as a nation any more.
We don’t have a sense of justice any more.
We don’t, as a nation, believe in the law any more.

Many, many years back, there was a crime of passion.
A naval officer called Nanavati shot his wife and her paramour.
Russi Karanjia of Blitz kept India focused on the case.
And the whole nation developed an opinion.
Including the then PM, Pt. Nehru.
(Driving opinion has its own dangers but the advantage was that everyone knew that the world was watching.)

If today, the bench knew that India was watching, would it acquit Manu Sharma so easily?
Would witnesses so easily turn hostile?

The Nanavati case awoke the collective conscience of a nation.
And Jessica Lall proved us that our consciences have gone to bed.

This is the time for Zorro.
A time for vigilantes.
This is the time for Biblical, barbarian justice.
An eye for an eye, ear for an ear.

Drag Manu Sharma to India Gate and hang him there.
For the murder of Jessica Lall.
And his father.
For the twin crimes of procreation and for believing that justice is there to be manipulated.

Will this happen?

Last year, Malayalam cinema had a rare box-office hit.
Directed by Jayaraj.
It had unknown faces and was pretty shoddily, frugally produced.

It featured 4 students who take the law into their own hands.
Who kill, maim and generally play Zorro.
It was a superhit.

It tells me a few things.
That audiences empathized with it.
And therefore, that there are millions out there who feel castrated.
That our society is full of impotent, angry, helpless youth.

And that, at a national level, always spells bloodshed.

8 comments:

  1. I couldn't agree more with you; the entire system is messed up. There needs to be a paradigm shift in the functioning ideology of the judiciary and the government. Think about it.... the entire system needs to be revamped.

    And: you write extremely well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks azadbali.
    Am one of those that wear the flag on thier sleeve.
    And have enough and more opportunities to do so.
    But this?
    Really don't have the objective temperament to shrug it off with a 'hum toh aise hi hain'.

    ReplyDelete
  3. now that the high court has reopened the case, and considering the kind of public outrage it has generated...i am very sure manu sharma will get what he deserves now.
    if not, people should put together the funds and order a hit on the bastard.

    ReplyDelete
  4. To quote from your post:
    "It’s getting caught therefore, that makes crime a crime.
    Not so much the act.

    We don’t have a collective conscience as a nation any more.
    We don’t have a sense of justice any more.
    We don’t, as a nation, believe in the law any more."

    That is true and, I suspect, has always been true. The conscience, collective or otherwise, is an instinctive understanding and appreciation of the difference between 'right' and 'wrong'. So is the ensuing 'sense of justice'. And like most instincts, the conscience is also shaped by a system of expected reward or punishment as a result of doing something. "You have been a good boy, Manu. You beat the shit out of that other kid. Here is a Cadbury for you." is a reward. "Bad boy, Manu! How dare you take 'no' for an answer? Have you no respect for your father's reputation? Where is my cane?" is a punishment. Probably the kind of reward and punishment that Manu grew up with and which shaped his behaviour.
    Similarly, our collective conscience is also shaped by such stimuli. "Papa, Raju's father is also an engineer with a government job... how do they have two cars and go for holidays to Singapore? You are also an engineer... why do we have only a Bajaj scooter?" After a lifetime of such examples around him, should we really judge him on why he is not outraged by "the castration of justice"?
    I think the sense of outrage leading to vigilante action comes from a sense of being personally wronged. I don't know about the Malayalam film that you refer to, but 'Rang De Basanti' from what I hear, is about the protagonists' taking the law in their own hand after their dead pilot friend is defamed by the corrupt minister. Not as a reaction to the overall 'corruption' issue. So till the time something goes wrong personally with us, we are content being spectators.
    So why did the Jessica Lal case move us so much? Is it because it hit too close home? An aspiring model, part of the swish set getting shot in front of hundreds more of people like us? "Shit, man! That can happen to me... It could have been that friend of mine working the (illegal) bar that night... My cousin / sister / daughter / girl-friend moves in the same society... THEREFORE, PEOPLE LIKE MANU HAVE TO BE SCARED OFF... THEY CANNOT GO ABOUT SHOOTING US." Remember reward and punishment? We want to 'punish' Manu not because of our 'moral outrage', but because he crossed a line by shooting and killing someone who is 'one of us', and therefore an example has to be made so that such things don't happen again. Would we have cared at all if Manu had shot two or three or six girls begging for money at a Delhi traffic light that night, for not going away and leaving him alone when being ordered to do so?
    We can 'order a hit on the bastard' as Harjee suggests, but do we feel similarly inclined against drunk stars driving over people sleeping on the pavements? I suspect not.
    Our collective conscience will be awakened only when we see the Manus (or Lalus or Sadhus or Shahabuddins...) marching into our living rooms. Until then, as our music channel VJs would say, "anything goes, as long as nothing of mine or my father goes!"

    ReplyDelete
  5. I couldn't agree with you more, Tony.
    It's a time for Zorro.
    And Robin Hood.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Mishraji,
    Thanks for the time.
    Two points.
    1. This has nothing to do with the realisation that this could happen to us.
    Callous though it may sound, it has nothing to do with the murder.
    My worry is to do with the brazenness of how the perpetrators got away with it.
    And these days, soceity's easy acceptance of it.
    2. The stimulus that led to this, is leading to finer stimuli. Baap ke paas paisa hai, toh baap ka raaj hai.

    ReplyDelete
  7. excellent tony. i think like the malayalam movie you cited, rdb also had a similar theme.

    i think we are set for a new india. the youth is certainly motivated about transforming india and it helps that over 60% of india is below 30-35 age group now.

    ps. did you have your appendix removed?

    ReplyDelete
  8. I don't know if Manu sharma will be punished for his crimes. But I do agree that our nation doesn't have a collective conscience anymore. We all are too engrossed in trying to make our lives better at a microscopic level with our jobs, pretty houses, a happy family life and a nice little vacation every year. We all live safe in the illusion that what happened to Jessica Lall couldn't possibly happen to us or anyone we loved. Bad things happen to other people. We think we are untouchable. I wonder if and when this blanket that blinds our society will disintegrate before our society does.

    ReplyDelete